Is Lime Lake, NY tap water safe?
The short answer
Machias Town Water District serves the most people here. EPA recorded a violation of the legal limit for nitrate here, the latest in 2024. A health benchmark is a level EPA screens with, not a legal limit. 1 health-based violation since 2016, resolved in EPA’s file.
The other utility, Country Club Homes, has no result above a legal limit or action level and no health-based violation since 2016 with no fix on record, in EPA’s and New York’s records.
A town can be served by more than one utility, and some homes are on private wells. The name on your water bill tells you which is yours, and your ZIP code narrows it down. They are listed by how many people each serves in Lime Lake, from EPA’s service area map; those it places no one in follow.
- Open report
Machias Town Water District
New York · serves 700 people · about 460 in Lime Lake
Violation on record (2024)EPA recorded a violation of the legal limit for nitrate here, the latest in 2024.
1 health-based violation since 2016, resolved
- Open report
Country Club Homes
New York · serves 100 people · nearly all in Lime Lake
Nothing in its records is above an EPA limit or health benchmark.
No health-based violations since 2016
Narrow it down by ZIP code
Certified filters for Lime Lake’s water
Each of these is certified, on a certifier’s listing, for a result found in Machias Town Water District’s water, which serves the most people here. Another utility’s report names what handles its own results.
Disclosure: TapBuff earns a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It does not change which standard or filter we name. As an Amazon Associate, TapBuff earns from qualifying purchases. How TapBuff makes money
Countertop reverse osmosis
Five years: $1,344, household of 3, cartridges included
Certified for: Nitrate; also lead, found below its limits
Aquasana SmartFlow Reverse Osmosis (AQ-SFRO2)
Under-sink reverse osmosis
Five years: $2,917, household of 3, cartridges included
Certified for: Nitrate; also lead, found below its limits
Culligan 10-Cup Pitcher with ZeroWater Technology (ZEROP10)
Pitcher
Five years: $5,103, household of 3, cartridges included
Certified for: Nitrate; also lead, found below its limits
Water testing near Lime Lake
What to test for at your tap
- Lead and copper. Both come mostly from a building’s own service line, solder and faucets, so a utility’s numbers can’t tell you yours. Machias Town Water District’s latest lead sampling in EPA’s records, 2024 to 2026, had a 90th percentile of 1.7 ppb: 9 in 10 of the homes it sampled were at or below that. The action level is 15 ppb, dropping to 10 ppb in November 2027, and EPA’s health goal for lead is zero. About lead.
- What Machias Town Water District’s results flag: nitrate. It is in the water the utility sends out, so a test of your tap mostly confirms it. Include it if you want a number for your own home.
- On a private well. No utility tests it. EPA’s advice is to test every year for total coliform bacteria, nitrates, total dissolved solids and pH. How to test well water.
The 3 labs New York certifies closest to Lime Lake, in a straight line. Call first: certification is test by test, and not every lab takes samples from homeowners.
Mcandrew Laboratory Inc.
Orchard Park, NY · about 25 miles
Certified for bacteria
Allegany County Community Environmental Laboratory
Belmont, NY · about 29 miles
Certified for bacteria
EMSL Analytical Inc.
Depew, NY · about 34 miles
Certified for bacteria, asbestos
Or test by mail
Tap Score sells lab tests as kits you fill at your tap and mail back. The sample goes to Tap Score’s lab, not one near you, so check that New York certifies it for the test you want.
Tap Score
- Lead and Copper Water Test, with a pH test strip: $55
- Essential City Water Test, 25 metals, 4 minerals, nitrate, fluoride, hardness and pH: $189
Return shipping included.
Tap Score says each kit ships to “an accredited laboratory” but doesn’t name it, so TapBuff can’t check it against New York’s list.
Prices from Tap Score’s own store on Oct. 22, 2026.
Which ZIP codes are in Lime Lake: Census 2020 relationship files. Which utilities serve them, and how many people: EPA SDWIS and EPA’s service area map. Each utility’s results: EPA UCMR 5, EPA SDWIS, and EPA’s and the state’s compliance monitoring, as its report lists them. How they are measured: methodology. Certified labs: NYS Environmental Laboratory Approval Program (ELAP), drinking water labs, as listed in TNI LAMS; distances from the Census 2020 ZIP code tabulation area gazetteer.
Near Lime Lake
Other towns in Cattaraugus County with a page of their own.
What to do next
- Read Machias Town Water District’s full reportEvery result with its dates, the violations, and the certification claim that handles each finding.Open the report
- Filters for NitrateRanked by certification and what they cost over five years.The best reverse osmosis systems, ranked
- On a private well?No utility tests a well. A certified lab test is the first step.How to test well water