Do you need a water softener?
Hard water isn’t a health risk, so a softener is a choice. Where extension services draw the line, what one costs to run, and when to skip it.
TapBuffUpdated 7 min read
The short answer
Only if hard water is causing a problem you want gone. Hardness isn’t a health risk, and the extension services at Penn State and Virginia Tech say water under about 7 grains per gallon (120 mg/L) usually needs no treatment. Above that, a softener ends scale and soap film, but it costs salt, water and upkeep, so get your own hardness number before a dealer tests it.
Start with your hardness number
Hardness is the calcium and magnesium in water, given in grains per gallon or in mg/L. One grain per gallon is 17.1 mg/L. USGS says hardness “is not a health concern, but it can be a nuisance,” and EPA sets no limit for it. So the question isn’t whether your water is safe. It’s whether the nuisance is worth what a softener costs to buy and run.
On city water, ask your utility. Nebraska Extension says a utility’s annual water quality report may give its hardness, and if it doesn’t, you can call and ask. TapBuff has hardness for 6,993 utilities, from states’ own results or the utility’s own report. Look up your ZIP below, and your utility’s report shows it where we have it.
Your utility may already soften it. Columbus, Ohio, softens its water to about 7 grains per gallon, which it calls moderately hard and “optimal for corrosion control.” WaterOne, in Johnson County, Kansas, softens with lime and soda ash. Asked whether you need a softener, it answers, “It’s a personal choice.” Utilities like these leave some hardness in on purpose: WaterOne says water that’s too soft can corrode pipes and release lead and copper from home plumbing.
On a well, test it. Penn State Extension says a hardness test costs about $20 at an accredited lab. Nebraska Extension says test kits and dip strips “can provide a good estimate of hardness.” San Francisco’s water utility found hardness strips agreed with its lab more than 80% of the time in moderately to very hard water. A dealer’s free test comes with a sales pitch. Penn State says “it’s best to have a third-party evaluation,” which “will protect you from being oversold.”
Where the line falls
No standard says when to soften, and the sources draw the line in slightly different places. The bands are USGS’s, the ones TapBuff’s reports use.
| Your water | What the sources say |
|---|---|
| Soft: up to 60 mg/L (3.5 grains) | Below every source’s line. Nothing to treat. |
| Moderately hard: 61 to 120 mg/L (3.5 to 7 grains) | Penn State: below 7 grains, probably no major scaling or soap film. The University of Minnesota: under 5 to 7 grains “may be acceptable to many homeowners.” Columbus softens its own water to about 7. |
| Hard: 121 to 180 mg/L (7 to 10.5 grains) | Where Penn State and Virginia Cooperative Extension put the line. Virginia says treatment “is only necessary when the hardness level is causing a problem.” |
| Very hard: over 180 mg/L (10.5 grains) | Purdue Extension’s general recommendation is to soften. |
What hard water does
USGS lists the signs. Soap leaves a film on your hands, and it takes more soap and detergent to get things clean. Glassware comes out cloudy. And scale “can reduce the life of equipment, raise the costs of heating the water, lower the efficiency of electric water heaters, and clog pipes.”
How much that scale costs depends on whose study you read.
- Independent tests found a modest loss. In 1978 the National Bureau of Standards measured a drop of 5 percentage points in the efficiency of old gas water heaters. In 1986, Battelle ran gas and electric heaters in four hard-water cities. After an estimated 20 years’ worth of scale, the gas heaters’ efficiency fell about 5%. The electric heaters’ “remained constant,” though scale made their heating elements fail from time to time.
- An industry-funded test found more. In 2009 Battelle tested heaters again, in a study commissioned by the Water Quality Research Foundation. Gas tank heaters lost 4% of their efficiency for every 5 grains of hardness, at 50 gallons of hot water a day. Showerheads on hard water lost 75% of their flow in less than 18 months. A tankless heater on 26-grain water stopped working after the equivalent of 1.6 years, when scale plugged the plumbing after it. WQA, the water treatment industry’s association, describes the foundation as aligned with it.
- Detergent. In tests the same foundation funded, released in 2011, softened water in a dishwasher cleaned as well as 10-grain water while using almost 30% less detergent.
What hardness doesn’t do is harm your health. Penn State Extension says calcium and magnesium “have no adverse effects and are, in fact, essential daily nutrients.”
Nor has a softener been shown to help eczema. A 2011 trial followed 336 children with moderate to severe eczema, all in homes with hard water. Some got a softener plus their usual care, and the rest usual care alone. After 12 weeks, the softeners “provided no additional benefit.” Parents who had one reported small improvements, which the authors put down to response bias. The families knew which group they were in; the nurses scoring the eczema didn’t. Penn State says some people find soft water makes skin smoother and hair silkier, but those “may not be substantial reasons to purchase” a softener.
What a softener costs
To buy. Penn State Extension puts the hardware alone at about $500 to $1,500. NDSU Extension gives retail prices of about $400 to $2,700, depending on size and type.
Salt. At 10 grains per gallon (171 mg/L), for a household of three using 80 gallons each a day, the 12 certified softeners TapBuff compares would use 168 to 198 lb of salt a year. Over five years that is $217 to $247 of salt at $9.88 a 40-lb bag, and the lowest five-year total for one, softener and salt together, is $716. Potassium chloride, which adds potassium instead of sodium, costs more: up to $25 a 40-pound bag, NDSU says, against $5 to $10 for sodium chloride.
Water. Each regeneration uses about 50 gallons, Penn State and Nebraska Extension say. EPA puts it at “25 gallons of water or more per day, or up to 10,000 gallons per year.”
Upkeep. Iron and bacteria can foul the resin. Penn State says some resins can’t be cleaned and need replacing.
The softener comparison works out each softener’s five-year cost at your own hardness, salt included.
When to skip it, or soften less
- Your water is under about 7 grains, or your utility already softens it.
- You only mind spots and crusty faucets. Tucson Water suggests cleaning showerheads and aerators with white vinegar, and running a cup of it through the dishwasher’s rinse cycle or the coffeemaker. It also suggests a detergent made for hard water.
- You’re on a septic system. Sources disagree. The University of Minnesota’s septic program says softener recharge water “does not need to go in the septic system” and suggests rerouting it. Penn State, Nebraska and NDSU Extension say it adds load. Texas allows it into a septic system only from a softener with demand-initiated regeneration, through an air gap. A 2012 Virginia Tech study, also commissioned by the Water Quality Research Foundation, found efficiently run softeners didn’t hurt septic tanks, but very inefficient ones may. Ask your county’s septic office before plumbing one in.
- Your area limits them. Sewer plants can’t take the chloride back out. Madison, Wisconsin’s sewer district says softeners make up about 57% of the salt reaching its plant. In parts of California, Water Code section 13148 lets local sewer and water recycling agencies ban new self-regenerating softeners and require old ones to be removed. The Inland Empire Utilities Agency bars installing or replacing one in seven cities, from Chino to Upland. It pays $300 to $2,000 to take one out.
Softening less is an option too. If scale in the water heater is the problem, Virginia Cooperative Extension suggests softening only the water that gets heated. Penn State says toilets, outside spigots and basement sinks can be bypassed. Nebraska and NDSU suggest one unsoftened cold tap in the kitchen for drinking and cooking, since softening adds sodium. What a softener adds has the figures. Both also advise against watering plants, lawns or gardens with softened water. Minnesota’s pollution control agency puts it simply: “Only soften to the optimal hardness.”
If you buy one
- Certified. Look for NSF/ANSI 44 with the claim “Hardness Reduction.” Softener or salt-free conditioner? explains the standard and what “Efficiency Rated” means.
- Demand-initiated. It regenerates by the gallons used rather than on a timer. The University of Minnesota says these use 26 to 60% less salt and 25 to 40% less water than time-clock softeners. It also counts a salt efficiency of 4,000 grains per pound or higher among the features that cut salt use.
- Sized to your house. Penn State gives an example: four people using 75 gallons each a day, at 10 grains, need 3,000 grains removed a day. A 20,000-grain softener would regenerate about every 6 to 7 days. The University of Minnesota says a softener should be sized to run three to five days between regenerations.
- Checked for iron first. A softener removes some dissolved iron, but the sources differ on how much. The University of Minnesota says up to 3 mg/L. Penn State says under 5 mg/L, with a pH above 6.7 and hardness of 3 to 20 grains. Iron that has already oxidized fouls the resin. On a well, the well water guide covers what goes first.
What’s in your water?
Questions people ask
- What hardness level needs a water softener?
- No federal limit sets one, so it’s a judgment call. Penn State Extension says water below 7 grains per gallon will probably not cause major scaling and soap film, and Virginia Cooperative Extension says water under 7 grains (120 mg/L) generally needs no treatment. Purdue Extension’s general recommendation is to soften water above 180 ppm, about 10.5 grains.
- Do water softeners help eczema?
- Not in the one full trial. In a 2011 study of 336 children with moderate to severe eczema in hard-water homes, a softener added to usual care did no better than usual care alone after 12 weeks. Parents with a softener reported small improvements, which the authors said were likely response bias, since families knew whether they had one.
- Does my city already soften its water?
- Some do. Columbus, Ohio, softens its water to about 7 grains per gallon, and WaterOne in Johnson County, Kansas, softens with lime and soda ash. A utility’s annual water quality report may list hardness, Nebraska Extension says, but if it doesn’t, call the utility and ask.
- How much does a water softener cost?
- Penn State Extension puts the hardware alone at about $500 to $1,500, and NDSU Extension gives retail prices of about $400 to $2,700. Then there’s salt: NDSU says about $5 to $10 a 40-pound bag for sodium chloride and up to $25 for potassium chloride. EPA says regeneration can use 25 gallons of water or more a day.
- Is softened water safe to drink?
- Yes, but it carries sodium: about 8 mg/L for each grain per gallon removed, Nebraska Extension says, so water softened from 10 grains has about 80 mg/L. Nebraska and NDSU Extension suggest leaving one cold kitchen tap unsoftened for drinking and cooking.
Sources
- Water Softening (updated September 8, 2025), Penn State Extension. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
- Iron and Manganese in Private Water Systems (updated May 29, 2025), Penn State Extension. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
- Water Tests for Households Using Public Water Supplies (updated August 26, 2022), Penn State Extension. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
- Virginia Household Water Quality Program: Hardness in Household Water (442-664, December 16, 2024), Virginia Cooperative Extension. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
- Interpreting Water Test Reports, Part One: Inorganic Materials (WQ-5), Purdue Extension. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
- Residential softening, University of Minnesota Water Resources Center. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
- Care and maintenance, University of Minnesota Onsite Sewage Treatment Program. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
- Drinking Water Treatment: Water Softening (Ion Exchange) (G1491, revised September 2014), Nebraska Extension. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
- Drinking Water: Hard Water (Calcium and Magnesium) (G1274, revised May 2016), Nebraska Extension. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
- Water Softening (Ion Exchange) (WQ1031, revised May 2022), NDSU Extension. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
- Hardness of Water (August 24, 2026), USGS. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
- Cation Exchange Water Softeners (updated May 8, 2026), U.S. EPA WaterSense. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
- A Randomised Controlled Trial of Ion-Exchange Water Softeners for the Treatment of Eczema in Children (PLOS Medicine, February 15, 2011), Thomas, Dean, O'Leary, Sach et al.. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
- Degradation of Gas-Fired Water Heaters (NBSIR 78-1460, June 1978), National Bureau of Standards, via NIST FireDOC. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
- The effect of hard water scale buildup and water treatment on residential water heater performance (ASHRAE Transactions, 1986), Talbert, Stickford, Newman and Stiegelmeyer, Battelle, via OSTI. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
- Independent Study Calls Softeners One of the ‘Very Best’ Household Energy Savers (April 13, 2010), Water Quality Research Foundation, via PR Newswire. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
- Studies Show Washing with Softened Water Can Significantly Cut Detergent Use, Energy Consumption (March 1, 2011), Water Quality Association, via PR Newswire. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
- About WQA, Water Quality Association. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
- Major Study Suggests Efficiently Run Softeners Do Not Hurt Septic Tank Performance (April 2, 2013), Water Quality Association, via Water Online. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
- 30 Tex. Admin. Code § 285.37, On-Site Sewage Facilities and Water Treatment Equipment and Appliances, Cornell Legal Information Institute. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
- Water Hardness, City of Columbus, Division of Water. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
- Do I Have Hard Water?, WaterOne. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
- Hard Water, City of Tucson, Tucson Water. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
- Home Test Kits, San Francisco Public Utilities Commission. Checked Nov. 13, 2026.
- For Residents (chloride), Madison Metropolitan Sewerage District. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
- Water Softener Removal Rebate Program, Inland Empire Utilities Agency. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
- California Water Code section 13148, California Legislative Information. Checked Oct. 4, 2026.
- Living Green 365: The skinny on water softeners (April 27, 2017), Minnesota Pollution Control Agency. Checked Nov. 19, 2026.
Published · Last reviewed . Where every figure comes from and how it is checked: the methodology.
Spotted something wrong or out of date? Write to info@tapbuff.com.
How TapBuff checks this
Limits come from EPA, standards from NSF’s own documents, and certifications from the certifier’s listing, never the box. Every source is dated.
MethodologyMore guides
- Home water test kits vs. a certified lab5 min
- Where to get your water tested for free7 min
- Coliform bacteria in your well: what to do next7 min
- A notice from your water utility: what it means and what to do3 min
- The best water filters for chromium-64 min
Read next
- Water softener or salt-free conditioner?A softener removes hardness and is certified to NSF/ANSI 44. A salt-free conditioner leaves it in and aims to stop scale, with no NSF/ANSI standard behind it.Read the guide
- Do you need a whole-house water filter?A whole-house system treats every tap. It’s the right tool for well germs, iron, hardness and radon, and the wrong one for lead. What EPA and NSF listings show.Read the guide
- Treating well water for the whole house, in orderTest first, then sediment, iron and sulfur, softener, and UV last. What each step handles, what certifies it, and why the order matters, per extension services.Read the guide
- Home water test kits vs. a certified labWhat home water test strips get right and wrong, what only a certified lab can measure, and how a state lab’s mail-in kit tests bacteria for $10 to $35.Read the guide
